By Sarah Sacks | Psychotherapist & Clinical Supervisor, Melbourne
If you’ve ever tried to find a therapist, you’ve likely found yourself comparing titles…
psychologist
psychotherapist
counsellor
social worker
On paper, they all look different. And in some ways, they are. But what most people are actually trying to understand is something else entirely:
What will this feel like?
Will this actually help me?
And how do I choose someone who is right for me?
The different ways therapists tend to work
While there is overlap, each profession tends to lean in a particular direction.
Psychologists (registered through Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency) are often trained in structured, evidence-based approaches.
This might look like:
Setting clear goals
Working with specific tools or frameworks (like CBT or ACT)
Tracking progress over time
For some people, this is exactly what’s needed. Especially if you’re wanting practical strategies and a more focused, short-to-medium term approach.
Psychotherapists and counsellors (often members of Psychotherapy and Counselling Federation of Australia or Australian Counselling Association) tend to work in a more relational and depth-oriented way.
This might look like:
Slowing things down
Exploring patterns and emotional responses over time
Paying attention not just to what you say, but what is felt and emerging
Working with the therapeutic relationship itself
This kind of work can feel less linear. But often leads to deeper, more integrated change.
Social workers (registered with Australian Association of Social Workers) often bring a broader, systems-aware perspective.
This might look like:
Understanding your experience in the context of family, work, and community
Supporting both emotional and practical challenges
Advocating or helping you navigate services
This can be especially helpful when life feels complex or overwhelming beyond just the internal experience.
Psychiatrists take a medical approach.
This might look like:
Assessment and diagnosis
Medication support
Shorter, more focused appointments
They are often part of a broader care team, rather than providing ongoing weekly therapy.
So… which one is “best”?
It depends on what you’re looking for. But also, not as much as you might think. Because across decades of research, one finding continues to stand out.
The therapeutic relationship, often called the therapeutic alliance, is consistently one of the strongest predictors of whether therapy will actually help.
Large-scale research shows a reliable correlation accounting for roughly 7–8% of therapy outcomes. That might sound modest, but in psychotherapy research, that’s significant.
More importantly, it’s consistent.
Across different modalities.
Across different diagnoses.
Across different types of therapists.
What this means in real terms
It means that the most important question isn’t:
What is their title?
It’s something closer to:
Do I feel understood here?
Can I be honest, even when it’s uncomfortable?
Do I feel some sense of trust building over time?
Is there both care and gentle challenge?
Because therapy isn’t just about insight. It’s about what becomes possible in relationship.
The importance of the therapeutic relationship isn't simply something clinicians have observed over time. A large 2018 meta-analysis by FlĂĽckiger and colleagues, drawing on 295 studies involving more than 30,000 clients, found a consistent relationship between the quality of the therapeutic alliance and therapy outcomes.
A quieter way of choosing
Qualifications, training and experience matter. They provide an important foundation for safe, ethical and effective practice. But research also reminds us that the quality of the therapeutic relationship matters. Once you've established that a therapist has the appropriate credentials, it's worth paying attention to something less easily measured: how you feel in their presence, whether you feel heard and understood, and whether there is a sense of trust that could grow between you.
After a session or two, you might ask yourself:
Do I feel met here?
Do I feel something shifting, even subtly?
Can I imagine continuing this work with this person?
If the answer is yes, that often tells you more than any list of credentials.
Final thought
I've written elsewhere about the importance of presence in therapy, and how the quality of the therapeutic relationship can matter just as much as the words we find to express ourselves.
Choosing a therapist isn't about finding someone with all the answers, or even the perfect therapeutic approach. It's about finding someone with whom you feel safe enough to explore what's difficult. Someone who can offer a different perspective, help you see things you may not yet recognise, and work alongside you as you come to understand yourself more deeply. Often, it is within the safety and trust of this relationship that meaningful change becomes possible.
If you're curious about what working together might be like, whether through individual therapy or clinical supervision, I'd welcome the opportunity to connect.
Remember, it is through relationship we heal.
Take care.
Love Sarah x